Though initially out of the plans for the new Community Center construction, the possibility of a green roof popped up again during Eden Prairie City Council’s Aug. 7 meeting.

However, despite the roof proposal coming in cheaper than earlier estimates, most council members were not in the mood to go forward with anything that involved increased spending.

“I’m not looking for new ways to spend money,” said Mayor Phil Young, after hearing the proposal.

The majority on the council decided not to explore the green roof option.

City Manager Scott Neal explained that, initially, the contractor proposed that the addition of green roof would increase the roof costs by $140,000 – too much for the city. After rejecting that offer, the contractor came back with a smaller price of $84, 870.

“We really did hope to add a green element to this project,” noted Neal.

Neal said the funding for the roof would come out of the storm water fund, since a roof (which would hold plants) could lesson storm water runoff.

Parks and Recreation Director Jay Lotthammer noted that this roof would be a visible space and would cut down on heating and cooling costs.

According to Gene Dietz, the director of public works, it would be good demonstration project for the city. It would give experience with a green roof in anticipation of directing private businesses to do more green building.

“We ought to be leaders rather than followers,” said Dietz.

Council members had a number of concerns and questions related to the project, including what the maintenance and expenses would be, and the track record of such a roof.

“I like the idea of this green roof,” said Council Member Kathy Nelson. She saw it in terms of paying more now, to pay less in the long run.

However, similar support was not found with Mayor Young or Council members Brad Aho and Jon Duckstad.

Duckstad also cited budget constraints as reasons to decline going forward with such a project.

Aho wondered how long it would take for a 6,350-square-foot green roof to recoup its costs.

Council Member Sherry Butcher noted that the city has made commitments to being a green city.

“I see this as one more step in that,” she said.

– Compiled by Leah Shaffer